Search » Arizona » Litchfield Park » Sincerity Insurance Solutions LLC

Sincerity Insurance Solutions LLC

Hi! I am Melissa Probst, the owner of Sincerity Insurance Solutions. I have been a licensed insurance agent since 2012. I am a single mom of one son, Elijah whom I adopted from foster care in 2009. In my free time I enjoy spending time with Elijah, hiking, spending time with friends and going back home to Wisconsin to see Family. Elijah plays basketball so most weekends are spent doing that. We moved to Arizona in 2016 and love the warmth that Arizona brings. My favorite part about working in insurance is helping people. I decided to go independent. What that means is I can sell insurance for many insurance companies. That allows me to advocate better for the customer’s needs as I have many options and not just one. A good day is when I can save my customer’s some money without cutting the quality or coverage of their policy. ​

Though sales is obviously what I do, I do not believe in hard sales tactics. I believe in listening to the customers needs and working on a plan that will solve those needs. I would much rather have a customer for life than to push a plan on a customer.


12320 West San Juan Avenue
Litchfield Park, Arizona 85340

Office Hours

  • Monday 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Tuesday 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Wednesday 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Thursday 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Friday 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Saturday By Appointment Only
  • Sunday By Appointment Only

Why our clients choose us

“I worked with this agency on my small business policy. I was sent back a quote fast and the email was organized spelling out each area for me so I could understand it and ended with the offer for an appointment to go over it. It was $600 less a year than my current policy as well. So I will be changing insurance soon. I appreciate the hard work and timely effort-Laura, Avondale, AZ”
“Melissa is awesome, she's helpful with any and all questions and if she can't help she'll let you know. She saved me $800 per month on my business insurance, can't beat that!-Starr, Milwaukee, WI”
“Worked with them to get insurance for my business. Since I am a contractor that only is me working I never get help when I work with agencies. They want the big guys. They helped me like my business mattered to them. I appreciate the help, taking the time to explain things to me and getting my certificate to my job so I can start work on the job. Thanks guys!-Chuck-Green Bay, WI”

We offer the following coverages for small businesses

General Liability (GL) Insurance

General Liability is the most common form of insurance for small businesses, as every single professional is required to have some form of general liability coverage. Coterie offers both standard, year-long policies, as well as flexible duration, project-based coverage through our partners.

Business Owners Policy (BOP)

A Business Owners Policy (BOP) is more versatile, and protects both a business owner’s business and property – all in one package (typically combining General Liability and Property Insurance). This type of insurance for small businesses can reimburse the policyholder for damaged personal property.

Professional Liability Policy (PL)

Professional Liability (PL), also known as Errors and Omissions, a type of liability insurance that covers you for failure to uphold contractual promises in mostly service-based professions.

General Liability Insurance
Business Owners Policy
Professional Liability Insurance

Why we trust Coterie Insurance

Coterie Insurance was built from the ground up to empower small businesses and insurance agents with:
  • Affordable and competitive pricing
  • Streamlined insurance quotes reducing the lengthy, time-consuming application process
  • Flexible coverage options designed for today’s small & micro businesses
  • Coverage backed by A+ rated (excellent) licensed insurers and reinsurers
  • Professional claims handling – when the unexpected occurs, Coterie is there to help
Construction Insurance: Why It's Important for Your Business
You have better things to think about than insurance

Through our partnership with Coterie Insurance, invest your time where it matters most — running your business — and enjoy the peace of mind that your hard work is protected by an insurance policy that meets your needs.

Agents & Brokers

Let's Work Together

Small Businesses

Policyholder Help Center

At Coterie, we are putting relationships at the forefront of small business insurance.

If you have any questions, Contact Us Today!